Unmasking Identity in Deceptive Calm: A Provocative Review of Patricia Skipper’s Controversial Novel
A raw, reflective look at a historical novel that tackles race in America, womanhood, and Black Identity with uncomfortable truths and bold storytelling.
Opening Impressions
Deceptive Calm, written by Patricia Skipper, weaves a narrative around a racially ambiguous young heroine, Vanessa, who is plagued by her secret Black identity. Deceptive Calm is anything but tranquil for those who shudder at profanity, racial slurs, and bland erotica — be warned. Skipper offers a plot of twists and turns that ultimately make this novel a page-turner, but it takes work.
A Setting Steeped in History
The author explores themes of racism, womanhood, and American history, with silence as a central metaphor for both societal oppression and emotional repression during a changing socio-political climate in the United States. The backdrop of complexity, coupled with social and gender themes, is the making of a powerful historical romance novel. Instead, the main character, Vanessa, lacks the depth of character, personality, and authenticity to relate to her readers beyond superficial events.
The scene opens with in-your-face Ku Klux Klan racism in the late 1960s, during the aftermath of Martin Luther King Jr.’s assassination and the subsequent riots. The narrative begins slowly, offering readers a glimpse into the antebellum legacy and post–Civil Rights era of South Carolina, told through the lens of an orphaned Black girl who is passing as white.
Although Vanessa lacks sufficient means, she eventually escapes the destitution of a segregated Catholic orphanage with the help of a college scholarship and the guidance of Sister Roe. Alongside her childhood friend Trisha, a white girl from a poor, segregated neighborhood, the story follows their lifelong relationship from adolescence into adulthood, all while Vanessa hides her true identity.
Womanhood, Repression, and Cultural Conflict
The two friends navigate college, womanhood, and romantic relationships in markedly different ways. Skipper highlights this powerful duality, casting Trisha and Vanessa as both victors and victims of the Free Love and feminist movements of the Hippie era. The Psychedelic Sexual Revolution unfolds against the backdrop of a strict Catholic upbringing and dominant American ideologies. Skipper skillfully illustrates these contrasts, allowing readers to experience this transformative period in American culture. Interwoven are themes of reproductive freedom, Roe v. Wade, and challenges to traditional family values.
Skipper immerses the reader in a range of heavy, thought-provoking themes that reflect the rapidly changing cultural landscape of the United States.
Passing and the Cost of Privilege
Nevertheless, Vanessa, in a panic to escape the inequalities and racism of the Old South, devises a plan to transform her identity. Assuming the identity of a deceased infant and passing as a white woman, seeking a life of ease and privilege.
The reader follows the often naïve and inexperienced protagonist through a turbulent journey marked by abuse, dysfunctional relationships, an unwanted pregnancy, low self-esteem, and deep shame. What initially seemed a golden path eventually curdles with deception, guilt, and emotional isolation — yet somehow, the story ends with a true unexpected romance. I applaud Skipper for her clever plot twists and the unexpectedly satisfying ending.
Narrative Shortcomings and Missed Depth
Yet, the novel misses terribly.
Skipper often resorts to info-dumping historical facts through dialogue, rather than integrating them into the narrative.
For example, detailed mentions of Southern Civil War Confederate leaders or a doctor’s extended monologue on abortion history often feel forced and disconnected from the plot. Totally uncomfortable for readers! These moments would be more effective if their significance were subtly implied or embedded in character experiences.
The Emotional Disconnect
More troubling is the lack of emotional depth in Vanessa’s character.
Greater attention to her internal conflicts — her fear, confusion, and suppressed identity — would offer a richer, more believable portrait.
Skipper misses an opportunity to develop Vanessa as a layered character torn between the comfort of passing and the heritage she’s severed herself from.
This disconnect from African American culture truly undermines Vanessa’s authenticity.
Despite being positioned as the tragic mulatto figure, she lacks sensory and emotional memories of Black life — the smells of Southern cooking, the warmth of her mother’s body, or even a sense of longing for cultural connection. These details could have powerfully underscored her internal conflict and deepened her complexity as a character. Skipper could have changed the origin of Vanessa’s arrival in the orphanage to grow the backstory and characterization.
There’s a missed opportunity to truly immerse readers in the rich tapestry of American history and Black identity during this tumultuous era.
Vanessa’s emotional responses often feel surface-level, as if she’s a passive victim rather than an active participant in her own life.
Final Thoughts & Rating
Even in her sexual experiences, she seems detached.
The explicit acts are often described as happening to her, lacking reflection or emotional resonance.
As a Catholic, one might expect deep inner turmoil and spiritual conflict, yet these too are underexplored and only mentioned briefly. Vanessa’s character does not mature emotionally as the story progresses — a significant gap considering the feminist and countercultural revolutions taking place around her.
It would have been powerful to witness Vanessa grow alongside the era’s rebellion against mainstream values. Her thoughts and feelings about sex, identity, and womanhood could have added emotional gravity to the plot and elevated her arc.
That said, the novel’s pacing improves dramatically as the story unfolds.
What starts out slowly gains momentum, and the later chapters are packed with unexpected turns that keep the reader engaged. Just when you think you’ve figured out the ending — boom! — Skipper surprises you.
I give the book 2 out of 5 stars.
Have you read Deceptive Calm? Share your take on its portrayal of race, identity, and womanhood below. Let’s unpack it together.
🌿 Want more?
Visit dariacreativeco.com for soulful branding, creative strategy, and devotional design.
